Joan Weber

My Experience Testifying for Arts Education

Posted by Joan Weber, Mar 16, 2011 11 comments


Joan Weber

Joan Weber

Joan Weber

As part of my pledge to Testify for Arts Education, I showed up at the Carroll County (MD) Board of Education meeting on March 9.

The room was full, as the board had recently released its preliminary budget. There were many people in the room who were there to protest cuts to school staffs, including nurse’s aids, teaching assistants and paraprofessionals.

They all wore printed labels saying “Together We Can Make a Difference.” They also all wore band-aids because, as they said, “Our hearts are broken.”

I was worried. I hadn’t brought anyone with me. (Note to self: Next time, bring people with me.)

I was sure that all these people would use the “Citizen Participation” time and my message of arts education would be lost. But, the agenda of the board was clearly divided between citizen participation and employee groups.

There were only two names on the Citizen Participation speakers’ list: mine and the chair of a parents’ group. (Note to self: Next time, bring lots of people with me.)

When my name was called, I went to the podium and delivered my prepared remarks. I spoke about an expanded definition of arts education, one in which the school system recognized the importance of arts specialists, teaching artists, and arts institutions.    

I finished.

Silence.

I had hoped for, I don’t know, a standing ovation?

An exclamation of “Oh, thank goodness you came! Now we understand what we need to do.” I guess I didn’t expect silence.

I sat down. I considered leaving, as the majority of the audience did as their issues came and went. But, I decided to stay until the end and try to meet some of the board members.

The meeting adjourned after about an hour in total. (Note to self: Tell people that the meetings are short and they should attend.)

I stood up and gathered my things.

A young woman came up to me and thanked me for my comments. She said that what I had said was exactly what she had always thought but didn’t know how to express it.

She is an elementary school teacher. She asked for a copy of my remarks so that she could bring them to her principal. I told her that I was disheartened by the silence, but she told me that she had been watching the audience. They were all paying close attention and were nodding their heads in agreement.

As soon as she left, a man approached. He said he was the Assistant Superintendent for Instruction. He wanted my contact information so that he could share it with the Director of Fine Arts. He thanked me for my remarks.

I asked if it would be possible to talk with the Superintendent. He shot out of the room to find him, but returned saying the board had gone into closed session. He recommended that I contact the Superintendent’s office to set up an appointment.

As I was driving away one of the board members was getting in her car. She saw me, smiled, and waved. (I noted her name in my notebook.)

And, that was that. It took three minutes of my time at a podium and I connected with everyone that I needed to at once.

It was painless.

It was in fact kind of exciting.

Lessons learned:
1.    Establish your bona fides with the Board. Take some of your time to delineate how you know what you’re talking about when it comes to arts education.

2.    Ask for something specific. In my case, I didn’t ask for increased funding in times of budget crunches; I asked for an expanded definition of what arts education should look like in the school system.

3.    Stay around after the meeting and connect with as many policymakers as possible. Ask to set up future meetings.

4.    Stay positive. If you stand up there and simply complain, they’ll stop listening. Don’t judge. It creates an antagonistic relationship.

To find the dates of the Board of Education meetings in your district, just go to the district website. They’ll list the meeting dates, how to get on the speakers’ list and a contact for any questions. I used the contact so that I knew what to expect when I arrived. They responded within minutes.

The Board of Education for local school systems determines the budget and curriculum for the district.

Their support is critical if you hope to increase arts education. You don’t need to have kids in the system to testify. You don’t even need to live there. You just need to show up.

Will you show up? Testify for arts education.

It is one of the easiest and most important things you can do for arts education.

11 responses for My Experience Testifying for Arts Education

Comments

Janice says
March 18, 2011 at 10:58 am

Joan - I would be very glad to have and share a copy of your remarks with others who advocate for arts education.

  • Please login to post comments.
March 17, 2011 at 8:58 am

Thanks, Rachel. We can combine our blogs. We'll take your Student Advocates to a Board of Education meeting!

  • Please login to post comments.
March 16, 2011 at 3:22 pm

Thanks, Joan, for sharing your Tale of Testifying! It includes valuable and practical tips for novice and experienced advocates alike. So encouraging and promising to hear that it's really that simple to make a positive impression, and, perhaps, move local discussions forward. I hope many follow your brave lead!

  • Please login to post comments.
March 18, 2011 at 11:34 am

Joan, Thanks so much for this honest and straightforward account of testifying before a school board. Your list of lessons learned is a primer for all of us. And I must confess--I signed up to testify before my local school board but I have not done so. Given the voodoo budget that the governor of Ohio has released (suggesting that there will be a slight increase is funding for education) my district--Cincinnati--is sure to face serious funding challenges in the coming year. So now, I do plan to testify. Honestly, I think many of us--at least myself--hesitate to do so because we dread the moment that you encountered after your remarks: silence. Those of us in the performing arts are particularly sensitive about the unresponsive audience. The thing you don't mention in your post but is so evident in your account is the courage it takes to step into a tough room. As we all know, it's easy to talk to one another (that is, arts supporters) because there is a given understanding that we all are, mostly, on the same page. So, thanks for this reality check on what it takes to go where your not expected, nor necessarily loved. Bravo!

Jim Palmarini

  • Please login to post comments.
March 18, 2011 at 3:56 pm

Look them right in the eyes, Jim, stony-faced though they may be! They will hear what you say. Then, summon all your acting skills and put on a show! Let me know how your testifying goes. It's important that these critical policy-makers hear from us.

  • Please login to post comments.
March 16, 2011 at 7:11 pm

I remember testifying, on more than one occasion, when there was either one person left from the elected representatives, or no one listening. I remember one time, the chair of the education committee had her baby there, who was spitting up on another council persons shoulder while I was testifying (as hard and as fast as I could...)

I think that anyone who is planning to testify, should be prepared for such events, and plan to power on through

  • Please login to post comments.
March 18, 2011 at 3:51 pm

You're bringing back great memories for me, too, of testifying in the State House and in Congress. But, at the Board of Ed, they televise the meetings so people are on more attentive behavior, though silent. It's worth it though. I imagine in NYC, with millions of students, it's much harder to be heard. I've recently moved to a rural area so I think they were glad for the new face. : )

  • Please login to post comments.
March 18, 2011 at 3:53 pm

Check in advance to see if they allow for technology as part of the presentation. You could bring 30 second clips of kids doing theatre. As we talked about in the Twitter chat this week, Boards of Ed love seeing kids do art.

  • Please login to post comments.
March 16, 2011 at 10:40 pm

Thank you, Joan. It's so helpful to hear the reality of what to expect - sounded harsh at first with the silence, but your connection with individuals sounds surprisingly positive. I hope to testify at the end of the month in Montgomery County. I shall take your tips and "notes to self" to prepare for my experience. Thank you!

  • Please login to post comments.
Victoria Plettner-Saunders says
March 19, 2011 at 7:55 pm

Thank you Joan. I absolutely agree with your comments about staying until the end and connecting with school board members and other decision makers. The personal approach has been extremely effective here in San Diego. I also like the part about not whining but asking for something specific.

In San Diego we had a long list of people recently speaking on behlaf of music ed. Students came with thier instruments and just played for thier two minutes. They didn't have to say a word.

  • Please login to post comments.
Ms. Karen Bradley says
March 25, 2011 at 4:41 pm

Joan! You rock, as always. I am glad we have you on our side in Maryland.

  • Please login to post comments.